Magnolia Shores

The home was lovely with attractive furniture and decor. It looked just as pictured online. The home is within an easy walk to a gorgeous beach and many restaurant options. The yard was set up nicely and in good shape. There is one thing to note for those who may care: the thermostat is locked at a minimum of 74 degrees overnight. We found the bedrooms to be quite warm and did not sleep great. And with the alarms on the windows we weren’t able to open them even when the nights were cooler. We did ask the host to lower just the overnight temp and they said they would lower it to 70. But in reality it was never lowered. Every night we woke up warm and the therm was still set to 74. Other than that the stay was great. But we personally would not stay there again due to poor sleeping temperature.

Dawn - Posted: 12/2/2025

Thank you for taking the time to share such a detailed review. We’re delighted to hear you enjoyed the home’s décor, convenient location, and well-maintained yard. We truly appreciate your feedback regarding the thermostat settings and window alarms. Your comfort is very important to us, and we’re sorry to hear this impacted your sleep. We’ll review these concerns with our team to ensure we can improve for future guests. Thank you again for staying with us, and we hope you’ll consider giving us another chance in the future.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Didn't meet the host. All done by email. Very efficient. Easy to use website. 2 bed house was perfect for a beach stay. Everything you need including a pool and outside seating area with mini golf. Only downside was one bathroom between four people but we managed for 2 days.

DENISE P. - Posted: 11/18/2025

Thank you for choosing us for your recent stay! Every review and every star you give us makes a huge difference to our success. If you enjoyed your stay, we'd love your 5-star review! We hope to host you again in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

This was a beautiful home! Clean, comfortable, and exactly as described. It was perfect for our family of four. Our kids loved the pool and putting green, and we loved being able to walk to restaurants, shops on Pine Ave, and the beach. We’ll definitely be back!

Geordie - Posted: 10/28/2025

Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re thrilled to hear the home was a perfect fit for your family and that you enjoyed the pool, putting green, and the convenient location near Pine Ave and the beach. It’s great that the kids had fun and you were able to explore the local shops and restaurants. We’d love to welcome you back anytime!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We just returned from our wonderful stay at Magnolia Shores. We’ve never been to AMI and so happy we chose to stay here. The location is prime… close to the beach, restaurants, shopping and all that Anna Maria Island has to offer. The home is decorated to perfection and the pool and putting green were a bonus for us. The outdoor shower was great after a day at the beach so we didn’t have to track sand all over the house. There is a cap on the AC temperature of 72 in the home; we typically like it colder, especially for sleeping, but we made do. We would return in a heartbeat. Thank you AMI Accommodations!

Megan - Posted: 10/5/2025

Hi, Megan, we’re so happy to hear you enjoyed your first trip to Anna Maria Island and that Magnolia Shores made it extra special! Sounds like you made the most of that great location and the pool and putting green, too. Thanks for mentioning the A/C setting, we’ll be sure to share that note with our team. We’d love to have you back with Anna Maria Island Accommodations anytime for another island getaway!!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Girls weekend with 3 besties, had a wonderful stay! Everything was better than the pictures!
Would go back again in a heartbeat!

Helene - Posted: 9/27/2025

Hi, Helene, thanks so much for staying with Anna Maria Island Accommodations at Magnolia Shores! We’re so happy you and your friends had a wonderful girls’ weekend and that the home exceeded your expectations. Sounds like it was the perfect getaway! Hope to welcome you all back to Anna Maria Island again soon!!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

The house looks brand new inside, Great back yard, very nice pool, lots of outside seating, including screen in porch, nice grill and even a putting green. Short walk to the beach and they have, Chairs, umbrellas, coolers and a cart to pull everything. Walking distance to several Restaurants and local bars. We will definitely be back soon! We had a Great time!

Scott - Posted: 9/26/2025

Thank you for the fantastic feedback, Scott! We’re so glad you loved the home’s fresh feel, the backyard with pool and putting green, and all the extras for beach days. Being able to walk to local restaurants and bars is such a bonus, too. We can’t wait to welcome you back soon with Anna Maria Island Accommodations!!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We just enjoyed a wonderful week on Anna Maria Island, and we’re so grateful to AMI Accommodations for hosting us. We stayed at the Magnolia Shores home, which has been beautifully remodeled and is fully equipped with everything you need. We loved relaxing by the pool and had a blast playing mini-golf.
The location was perfect—just a 5-minute walk to the beach and surrounded by great restaurants. Check-in and check-out were seamless, and the communication from AMI Accommodations was excellent, making everything so easy for us.
We’d love to return in the near future and highly recommend both this home and AMI Accommodations to anyone planning a stay on Anna Maria Island.

Angel - Posted: 9/12/2025

Thank you so much for your wonderful review, Angel! We’re thrilled Magnolia Shores was the perfect spot for your island getaway and that you enjoyed the pool, mini-golf, and being so close to the beach and local dining! We’re glad check-in and communication were smooth with our Anna Maria Island Accommodations team, and we’d love to welcome you back anytime for another stay in paradise!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Magnolia Shores was our dream vacation home. It was so beautiful and tastefully decorated, everything was new and in spotless condition. The kitchen had everything you could ask for and the pool was a true highlight. The whole pool deck is very well laid out and offers lots of privacy and style.The patio is screened, but overall there were no bugs on the property. We enjoyed the putting green and the outdoor shower (you even can take a hot shower outside).The house is perfectly located, only two blocks from the beach, within 4 minutes walking distance. You do not need to search for a special beach on AMI, the one near the house is just perfect. We've been to many beaches all over the world but have never seen this fine, white powdered flour-like sand. Right next to it is the Sandbar restaurant, a great spot for a sunset dinner. Many other restaurants and cafes are nearby.The beach equipment in the garage is high quality, with a large handcart and 6 beach chairs, umbrella, and sand toys. We didn't try out the gas grill, but will do so next time...This house is a dream house for families or a small group. It is bright, imoeccably clean and smells fresh and welcoming. The contact with the host A.M.I. Accomodations was smooth, friendly, and professional throughout our stay. I would give more stars if I could. Only downside was that we only stayed for three nights. Next time, it will definitely be longer.

Daniel - Posted: 9/7/2025

Hi, Daniel, thank you for staying with Anna Maria Island Accommodations! We’re thrilled to hear Magnolia Shores was your dream vacation home and that you enjoyed everything from the spotless interior to the pool, putting green, and beach gear. Sounds like you made the most of the perfect location near the Sandbar and that powdery white sand! We’d love to welcome you back for a longer stay next time, your kind words mean the world.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

The home was super cute, we loved the decor and the backyard had so much to do including a pool, mini golf and screened in patio. Thank you again!

Brittany - Posted: 8/31/2025

So glad you enjoyed your stay, Brittany! We love hearing that the backyard amenities and decor made the home a hit. Thanks for choosing Anna Maria Island Accommodations, we’d be happy to welcome you back anytime!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

The house was beautiful and the outdoor space was very nice for our family.

Philip Gordon - Posted: 8/20/2025

Thanks so much for your kind words, Philip! We’re delighted you enjoyed the home and that the outdoor space was a great fit for your family time together. We’d love to welcome you back with Anna Maria Island Accommodations for another relaxing island getaway!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Awesome stay! What a beautiful house and pool. We really enjoyed our time - totally walkable to Pine Ave for shopping and food. Beach walk was about 5 minutes as well. Thanks!!

Mike - Posted: 8/12/2025

Thank you so much for the wonderful review, Mike! We're delighted to hear that you had an awesome stay and enjoyed our beautiful house, pool, and the convenient location of the home. Your feedback is greatly appreciated, and we're thrilled that you had a great time. We hope to have the pleasure of hosting you again in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Adoramos hospedagem na casa , tudo é incrível tudo havia na casa para suprir suas necessidades, adoramos a decoração a limpeza a localização o bairro muito tranquilo, não vejo a hora de voltarmos obrigado.

Watylas - Posted: 8/9/2025

Agradecemos sinceramente o seu comentário positivo sobre a nossa hospedagem. Fico feliz em saber que você e sua família tiveram uma ótima estadia e que todos os aspectos, como a decoração, limpeza e localização, atenderam às suas expectativas. Esperamos recebê-los novamente em breve e que possam desfrutar de mais momentos agradáveis em nossa propriedade. Mais uma vez, muito obrigado pela preferência e avaliação.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Property was beautiful inside and outside. We spent so kuch time outside with the family in the pool and putting on the green, and of course taking the quick walk to the beach. Definitely recommend this property for a family vacation getaway.

Sue - Posted: 8/6/2025

Hi, Sue, thank you so much for the wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that you and your family had such an enjoyable stay at our property. It sounds like you made the most of all the wonderful amenities, from the pool to the putting green to the short walk to the beach. We strive to provide a top-notch experience for all our guests, and it's rewarding to know that we succeeded in your case. We truly appreciate your recommendation and look forward to welcoming you back for another family vacation getaway!!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Wonderful place to stay for a family with kids. The pool and backyard is like an oasis and there’s lots to do all around. Walking to the beach and Pine Ave was a breeze. They were very responsive and helpful throughout the stay. Would absolutely come back!

Katie - Posted: 8/1/2025

Thank you so much for the wonderful review, Katie! We're thrilled to hear that you and your family had such an enjoyable stay. It makes us happy to know that you found the pool, backyard, and surrounding area to be a true oasis. We're grateful for your kind words about our responsiveness and helpfulness during your stay. We look forward to welcoming you back in the future!
Thank you,
Anna Maria Island Accommodations

Anna Maria Paradise staff

The house was perfect for our family of three. We loved that we could walk to the beach or bay, hang out in the pool, and walk to all the shops and restaurants on Pine Ave. Didn't use our car once. The house had all the amenities we needed and more. The property management company was very responsive. We'd definitely stay at this house again and would be happy to stay at other houses managed by this company.

Rachael - Posted: 7/18/2025

Thank you for choosing us for your recent stay! Every review and every star you give us makes a huge difference to our success. If you enjoyed your stay, we'd love your 5-star review! We hope to host you again in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

My family had a wonderful stay at Magnolia Shores! The house was in a wonderful location and in walking distance to the beach, restaurants, and shopping. The house was beautifully decorated and well appointed. Our kids loved the pool and putting green, and we enjoyed the screened in porch with table and seating. Look forward to booking this house again in the future!

Allie - Posted: 7/14/2025

Hi, Allie, thank you so much for your wonderful review of Magnolia Shores! We are thrilled to hear that your family had a fantastic stay and that the house, amenities, and location were exactly what you were looking for. We truly appreciate your kind words and look forward to welcoming you back in the future!!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

This place was a dream! Located walkable to the beach and a couple delicious breakfast spots (i.e: Northshore Cafe). We had an entire itinerary and ditched it just to hang out at the house, it was truly spectacular. They provided everything, it was IMPECCABLE, homey, comfortable and the pool/backyard was a dream. The hosts were very communicative and professional and let us check-in an hour earlier which we really appreciated. I would come back here time and time again and stay in this exact house. Great experience.

Laura - Posted: 6/22/2025

Hi, Laura, thank you so much for the wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that you had such a fantastic stay at our property. It's great to know that you enjoyed the convenient location, the amenities, and the hospitality of our team. We truly appreciate your kind words and look forward to welcoming you back in the future!
Thank you,
Anna Maria Island Accommodations

Anna Maria Paradise staff

House was clean. Nice pool. Close to beach and shops.We had a wonderful time!

carlos - Posted: 6/13/2025

Everything was as described and even better. The place was professionally cleaned and maintained and everything worked as it should. No complains here.

Alen - Posted: 6/9/2025

Thank you for choosing us for your recent stay! Every review and every star you give us makes a huge difference to our success. If you enjoyed your stay, we'd love your 5-star review! We hope to host you again in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Joanna M. - Posted: 5/30/2025

Without a doubt the pre arrival communication, during the stay communication, and post stay communication was stellar. AMI definitely does the right job in giving all the information you need and stays in touch during the stay
The property was perfect, from decor, to the pool and the mini golf. The location could not have been better only 1 block from the beach and right by all the little shops and restaurants on the quieter north end.
If there was any notes on the stay it was the the air did not go below 72. (we like it cold!) We requested a change and they worked to lower it to 70. While it wasn't as cold as we hoped their repeated call backs checking in on us and the responsiveness was absolutely first class. We will definitely stay again.

Julio - Posted: 5/25/2025

Hi, Julio, thank you so much for your thorough and positive review of your stay with us. We're delighted to hear that you had a wonderful experience, from the pre-arrival communication to the property itself and its convenient location. Your feedback about the air conditioning is appreciated, and we're glad we were able to address your needs promptly. We look forward to welcoming you back again in the future. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we're grateful for the opportunity to provide you with an exceptional stay.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We had a fantastic stay in this home! It is perfect and overly accommodating! So many extras like a wagon for the beach, toys, plenty of towels, the outdoor shower was so convenient for washing off our little one…. I can’t even name everything we loved there was so much. On top of that, the home is so lovely and perfectly designed, very clean, walkable to everything we needed, just perfect. We would stay again!

Kathryn Rose - Posted: 5/10/2025

This house is a jewel! We immediately felt at home. The interior has been decorated very nicely with lots of love to the details. The pool and deck area is beautiful and we enjoyed chilling out and having BBQ there. It‘s a 5 minute walk to the white sandy beach.
The house has lots of extras, like floaties for the pool, beach chairs and a little trailer to load everything in, enough beach towels, board games and more. And everything in new condition.
Check-in and check-out worked perfectly and there is a binder with all the important information.
The house across the street is under construction but we weren’t bothered by the minor noise.
All in all it was a great experience and we enjoyed it to the fullest.
We‘de love to come back one day!

Mirjam - Posted: 5/1/2025

.

Lauren - Posted: 4/27/2025

Thank you for your review!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Beautiful place to stay!

Natalia - Posted: 4/12/2025

Natalia, thank you for the positive review! We're delighted to hear that you enjoyed your stay with us. Your feedback is greatly appreciated and helps us continue to improve our services. We look forward to welcoming you back in the future.

Anna Maria Paradise staff